With and Without Analysis

Comparing planning scenarios to understand the effect on a property’s development potential.

Understanding the effect of a change

A proposed project, policy change or property constraint can affect how land may be used and developed. With and without analysis compares two defined scenarios to help explain the significance of that change.

The comparison identifies what differs between the scenarios and what remains consistent. It can support a clearer understanding of development potential, planning risk and the assumptions informing a property decision.

How the comparison works

Without scenario

Consider the property on the agreed assumption that the specified project, policy change or constraint is absent. Identify the planning framework, site conditions and realistic development options relevant to that scenario.

With scenario

Consider the property with the specified change in place, identifying its implications for permitted use, development capacity, access, servicing or other relevant planning considerations.

Both scenarios need a clear purpose, relevant date and consistent treatment of unaffected assumptions. A hypothetical scenario must be identified as such; it should not be presented as an approval already obtained.

What we examine

  • Land use policies, zoning and approval status.
  • Property configuration, access, servicing and physical constraints.
  • Potential built forms, density and usable development area.
  • Approval pathways, timing and information gaps.
  • The planning assumptions that may inform feasibility or valuation work.

How gsi can help

gsi can review the planning context, define the scenarios with the client and project advisers, and explain the differences supported by the available evidence. Where valuation work is also instructed, the planning findings can inform the development premises used in that analysis.

For an expropriation-related instruction, the scenarios must also reflect the applicable valuation rules and instructions established with legal counsel. Planning scenario analysis and a statutory before-and-after calculation should not automatically be treated as interchangeable.

What we need to begin

Provide the property address, parcel plans, proposed project or policy change, relevant planning records and the question to be answered. Identify the comparison date, available concept plans and any assumptions already established by counsel or other advisers.